2 Options Comparative Evaluator

Acting as a Comparative Evaluator, your task is to take 2–N options and determine which one is best, where each option excels or falls short, and why. Follow this structure exactly:

Context & Options Intake
Read the brief context description.
List each option (A, B, C, etc.) with a one‑sentence summary.

Criteria Definition
Identify the evaluation criteria. Use any user‑specified criteria or default to:
• Effectiveness
• Cost or effort
• Time to implement
• Risk or downside
• User or stakeholder impact

Assign a weight (1–5) to each criterion based on its importance in this context.

Option Assessment
For each option, rate its performance against each criterion on a 1–5 scale.
Provide a one‑sentence justification for each rating.

Comparative Table
Create a markdown table with options as rows, criteria as columns, and ratings in the cells.
Calculate a weighted total score for each option.

Strengths & Weaknesses
For each option, list its top 1–2 strengths and top 1–2 weaknesses drawn from the ratings.

Quick Verdict Line
Provide a one‑sentence TL;DR: “Best Choice: X because …”.

Overall Recommendation
Identify the highest‑scoring option as the “Best Choice.”
Explain in 2–3 sentences why it wins.
Note any specific circumstances where a different option might be preferable.

Tiebreaker Logic
If two options are neck‑and‑neck, specify the additional criterion or rationale used to break the tie.

Optional: Hybrid Option Synthesis
If combining two or more options creates a superior solution, describe how to synthesize A + B (etc.) and under what conditions to use it.

Transparency & Trade‑Offs
Summarize the key trade‑offs considered.
Cite any assumptions or data gaps.

Output Format:
Criteria & Weights: Bulleted list
Comparison Table: Markdown table
Strengths & Weaknesses: Subheadings per option
Quick Verdict Line: Single-line summary
Recommendation: Numbered conclusion
Tiebreaker Logic: Short paragraph (if needed)
Hybrid Option Synthesis: Optional section
Trade‑Off Summary: Short paragraph

---

CONTEXT AND OPTIONS:

Here are the 2 options
Option1: [Option 1]
Option2: [Option 2]

How to customize this prompt

This prompt includes fill-in-the-blank fields. Before copying it, replace each placeholder with your own details by answering the questions below.

1. Option 1
2. Option 2